Our favorite fish sandwich in Key West – from an island legend.

Outdoor seating at the casual B.O.'s Fish Wagon
B.O.’s Fish Wagon, classic “Key West”, serves up our favorite island sandwich.

When people ask us where to get a great fish sandwich in Key West, this is where we send them: B.O.’s Fish Wagon.

Yes, it looks like a shack that a hurricane blew to pieces. That’s because it has…more than once.

Owner Buddy Owen (hence the B.O.’s…you didn’t think it mean’t something else, did you?) has been through a few hurricanes, and afterwards picks up the pieces and nails it all back together. A true Key West character, this man is beloved by many.

Outstanding fresh fish sandwiches are served on fresh-baked Cuban bread with B.O.’s famous Key Lime sauce. Also offered are burgers, conch fritters, french fries, hot dogs, and other delicious finger foods. Outdoor covered seating gives a great view of island life near the Historic Seaport.

Location: The small eatery sits on the corner of Caroline and William Streets, across the parking lot from the Waterfront Market.

Hours: Open every day, 11:00 am – 8:59 pm. (subject to their policy as pictured)

B.O.’s Fish Wagon Menu

Fish Sandwich (fried) $8.75, (grilled) $9.75
Shrimp Sandwich $9.25
Soft Shell Crab Sandwich $10.00
B.O.M.F. Burger (Mother’s Finest) – $7.75
BBQ Chicken Sandwich – $7.25
Teriyaki Chicken Sandwich – $7.25
Oyster PoBoy – $8.75
Cracked Conch Sandwich – $12.50
Chili Dog $6.00
Hot Dog $4.50
Slaw Dog $5.50

Appetizers & Sides
Grilled Shrimp on a Skewer (grilled, teriyaki, italian, or bbq) – $5.50
Conch Fritters: 1/2 dozen $6.25, 1 dozen $9.25
Fries: Large $4.00, small $2.00.
Beans & Rice – $3.75
Bowl of Chili – $4.50
Coleslaw – $2.50

Grilled Scallops with one side (rice & beans or salad or fries) – $14.00
Fish & Chips: small $8.75, large $15.00
Fish, Conch Fritters, & Fries: $13.50
Fish Dinner – Grilled $17.75, Fried $15.75 includes 2 sides (choices include: salad, beans & rice, fries, or coleslaw)
Shrimp Dinner – Grilled or Fried $15.25 includes 2 sides (choices include: salad, beans & rice, fries, or coleslaw)
Fish Nuts with fries or beans & rice – $8.75
Shrimp & Chips $10.25

Fried Fish $10.50, Grilled Fish $11.50
Fried Shrimp or Grilled – $10.00
Soft Shell Crab – $12.00
Grilled Chicken – $9.75

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Key Lime Ade, bottle water, iced tea – $2.00
Domestic Beer: Bud, Bud Light, Rolling Rock, Miller Lite, Michelob Ultra, & O’Douls – $3.75
Corona, Landshark, & Heineken – $4.75
Wine: Chardonnay, Pino, Merlot, White Zin – $4.75