Jimmy Buffett’s Margaritaville Cafe

Jimmy Buffet's restaurant in Key West, home of the cheeseburger in paradise.

Margaritaville Cafe - where legions of fans enjoy island drinks and cheeseburgers in paradise.

Margaritaville Cafe – where legions of fans enjoy island drinks and cheeseburgers in paradise.

Just saying the word Margaritaville can bring many a Jimmy Buffet fan to near frenzy.

Thoughts of beaches & blenders, pirates & sailors, fill the minds Parrotheads and frequently send them on a one-way course to Key West.

And why not? Buffet was singing about the American Caribbean we love – Key West.

So while in town, if you need a Buffet Break, head to Margaritaville Cafe for some of the cold drinks, cheeseburgers (of course), and songs by the man himself.

Chances of him showing up and playing a tune? They increase with every blender drink.

Location: 500 Duval Street

Margaritaville Cafe Menu

  • Soups, Salads, Starters

    • Bahamian Style Conch Chower – $5.25/bowl, $4.74/cup
    • Black Bean Soup – $4.25/bowl, $3.75/cup
    • Shrimp Salad – with jalapeno mayo – $7.95
    • Avocado, Tomato, & Red Onion Salad – $5.95
    • Tropical Fruit Plate – with honey yogurt dredding – $7.25
    • Caesar Salad – $5.25
    • House Salad – $3.95
    • Conch Fritters – $6.95
    • Squid Rings – $5.95
    • Key West Shrimp – peel & eat em – $10.25
    • Smoked Local Fishspread – with Cuban crackers – $6.25
    • Couch Potatoes – fries topped with chili, cheese, & onions – $5.95

  • Sides

    • Vegabtable of the Day – $3.95
    • French Fries – $3.75
    • Potato Salad – $3.75
    • Cole Slaw – $2.95
    • Red Beans & Rice – $4.25
    • Peas & Rice – $4.25
    • Black Beans & Rice – $4.25
    • Side Caesar Salad – $4.25

  • Paradise Found

    • Cheesebruger in Paradise – served with fries – $8.95 (also served like the song says, add bacon – $1.50)
    • Caribbean Club Sandwich – hand pulled roast chicken w/ bacon and our own avocado mayo – $7.95
    • Local Fish Sandwich – plenty of tartar sauce suggested, chargrilled to perfection or deep fried to a golden brown – $8.95
    • Fresh Yellowfin Tuna – chargrilled or bar-b-que – $9.75
    • Broiled Yellowtail Snapper Sandwich – $9.50
    • Delta Catfish Rueben – crispy fried, farm fresh catfish grilled on Texas toast w/ Swiss cheese, sauerkraut – $8.75
    • Fish and Chips – $9.75
    • Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken – $8.75
    • Caesar Salad with Key West Pink Shrimp – $9.95
    • Caesar Salad with Key West Pink Shrimp & Avocado – $10.75
    • Blackened Hotdog (aka BHD, Cajun style) – served with french fries $5.25 (w/ chili cheese & french fries – $6.95)

    Sandwiches come with choice of potato salad or coleslaw

  • Platters

    Below items come with choice of 2 side dishes

    • Local Catch of the Day – chargrilled or deep fried to a golden brown – $15.75
    • Fresh Yellowfin Tuna – chargrilled or bar-b-qued – $17.95
    • Native Yellowtail Snapper – broiled to perfection – $16.95
    • Half Chicken – oven roasted or bar-b-qued – $13.75
    • Key West Pink Shrimp – $18.75 (choices include: skewered and chargrilled to perfection, w/andouille sausage, Jamaican jerk style with a special blend of Caribbean spices, bar-b-qued style w/ our own tailgate sauce, deep fried to a golden brown, or Barbados style with our own Caribbean sweet and sour sauce)


  • Plates

    • Shrimp Scampi – Key West pink shrimp sauteed in butter & fresh garlic, served over rice w/ veggies – $17.95
    • Enchilado de Mariscos – a Cuban soulfood stew w/ local fresh fish, shrimp, and scallops, served with rice and beans – $17.95
    • Bar-B-Que Ribs – a full slab of baby back ribs, slow cooked and finished on the chargrill w/ our own sweet and spicy sauce, served w/ potato salad – $16.95
    • Andouille Sausage – New Orleans favorite, spicy smoked sausage, grilled and served with a belly full of red beans, rice, and Cuban bread – $14.25

  • Desserts

    • J. B. Key Lime Pie – $4.50
    • Key West Ice Cream Co. Ice Cream – $4.75
    • Eli’s Cheesecake – $4.95
    • Chocolate Suicide Cake – $5.50


  • Island Drinks

    Margarita – frozen or on the rocks – $6.25
    Margaritaville Gold Margarita – we use our own premium Margaritaville Gold Tequila – $6.95
    Uptown Margarita – $7.95
    Natural Fruit Margaritas & Daquiris – strawberry, raspberry, banana, peach, lime, mango, guava, or passion fruit – $6.75
    Pina Colada – $6.75
    Calypso Daquiri – pina colada w/ a splah of kahlua – $6.95
    Rum Runner – a Keys favorite – $6.95

  • Beer

    Corona, Corona Light, Heineken, Amstel Light, Budweiser, Bud Light, Miller Light, Coors Light, Michelob Ultra, Key West Sunset Ale, Red Strip, Kalik – $3.50 – $4.00

  • Wine List

    Champagne

    • Moet & Chandon Cuvee Dom Perignon – $195.00
    • Moet & Chandon White Star – $65.00
    • Domain Chandon Brut – $36.00
    • Korbel Brut – $33.75

    White Wine

    • Chardonnay, Jordan Sonoma – $39.50
    • Chardonnay, Mondavi Napa – $37.50
    • Chardonnay, Kendall Jackson, Santa Rosa – $29.50
    • Sauvignon Blanc, Silverado, Napa – $27.50
    • Poilly Fuisse, Joseph Drouhin, France – $36.50
    • Pinot Grigio, Santa Margherita, Italy – $33.50

    Red Wine

    • Merlot, Columbia Valley – $29.50
    • Pinot Noir, Ninth Island, Tasmania – $28.50
    • Cabernet Sauvignan, Rodney Stron, Sonoma – $29.50
    • Toscana, Antinori, Italy – $29.50

1-877-463-6539 Click here to call us